My senior portraits have come and gone. I actually like most of them. They're not terrible. My smile is decent.
And yet the airbrushed glories are not posted [on facebook]. I will tell you why.
About nine months ago, my friend Edward Chow was handed an old film camera by his father. It was the beginning of what has so far been a brilliant endeavor into photography. Since last Christmas, he has poured his time, energy and resources into developing his photography skills, and I would venture to say they have paid off. Edward takes good pictures. His work makes you pause, as only good art can. It makes you contemplate for half a moment, even if you can't pin down exactly what it is in his work that made you stop. The humanity he frames always brings a small smile to my face.
Those of you who know Ed also know that he's not exactly the most passionate guy. Photography changed that. If you're ever looking for him, look for the Chinese kid lugging around a 25-pound camera bag, quite possibly puttering around San Francisco taking pictures of the homeless. Look for the guy who looks up with a gleam in his eye when you ask about his work. Edward considers himself a member of the 'old guard' in photography, that group which considers even editing out the red-eye in a badly lighted shot questionable. Photography matters to him.
When the time for senior pictures rolled around, Edward decided not to participate. For him, it was a matter of professional and personal honor. Having perused some of the work available publicly at leongphotography.com, he decided that he could not, in good conscience, allow Leong Photography to reproduce his image. It was his professional opinion that the quality of the work was lacking, the prices exorbitant, and, in short, that the business was unbecoming to the name of professional photography. (Feel free to ask him to elaborate further. I'm sure he'll be glad to.) So he opted out. He chose not to have his senior portrait taken, in the full knowledge that it meant his picture would be missing in the yearbook. His senior yearbook.
Administration responded to Edward's decision by suspending his privilege to participate in the Yearbook elective.
Their justification? In not taking his senior portrait, Edward was inconveniencing the yearbook team. And "just like a sports team", if Edward didn't cooperate then he could be kicked out.
The punishment does not fit the crime, if what he he has done can even be called a crime. It hurts no one but the student body, as it deprives us of a brilliant and rising photographer who has poured his heart into faithfully recording the life around him. And yet Administration insists that is is somehow in Edward's and the student body's best interests to to suspend his yearbook privileges.
Let us say I missed a volleyball game for personal reasons of pure selfishness. It would be the coach's decisions as to whether or not to chastise me. Sure, Administration could step in and declare that I am not pulling my own weight on the team. They could point to their authority and revoke my participation. But forgive me if the image that comes to mind in this scenario is not a big, kind and benevolent elder brother who only has my best interests in mind, but rather long and clammy fingers of slime that refuse to let go simply because they feel as if they have to hold on.
Administration did not have that right to suspend Edward from yearbook. It was a yearbook request that the senior portraits be standardized through Leong Photography. If a member of their own team chose not to comply, it should have been their prerogative to suspend him. I see no "transforming lives for the glory of God". I merely see a decision based on authoritarian principles and a foolish decision that administration has yet to revisit.
In Edward's support, I have chosen not to post my senior pictures. I am also considering submitting a request that the yearbook staff not reproduce my senior portrait in the yearbook.
No comments:
Post a Comment